James C. Barnett
GA Registered Forester
Mark D. Barnett
GA/AL Registered Forester

10800 Alpharetta Hwy.
Suite 208, #A8
Roswell, GA  30076


E-Mail Fall Line Consultants

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Home
News
Links
Wildlife
Selling Timber
Principals
Newsletter
Mission

 

Summer 2002
Newsletter Logo
FALL LINES
Fall Line Forestry Consultants, LLC

 

I
N
S
I
D
E

Fall Line Consultants' owners

 
1 Standing Timber Price Report
2 Thin by Whole-Tree Chipper
3 French Invade Georgia
4 Forestry Commissioner Speaks!
5 Intensive Pine Management
6 Wood Facts
7 Land of Enchantment

TIMBER PRICES

Sawtimber Prices Up

Timber Mart South Market Newsletter, in its 1st Quarter, 2002 issue reports "South-wide average pine sawtimber stumpage prices increased 1% over last quarter, up over 6% from the same period last year."  "... Chip-n-Saw [small sawtimber] south-wide average stumpage prices were down 1% for the quarter but still up over 4% from the 1st Quarter 2001".

Sawtimber Stumpage Price Trend

The strong Southeastern timber market is credited to three factors --

bulletRecently enacted 29% duties on lumber imports from Canada, coupled with restricted logging in the National Forests of the West.  Much of America's pulp and paper industry is now concentrated in the South.
bulletThe housing industry has been in strong-growth mode since the mid-1990's.  Nationwide, housing starts rose 2.2% in 2001 (and 2.5% in the South).  Housing forecasters expect the sector to remain robust as the economy recovers from recession and while historically-low interest rates prevail.
bulletIncreased consumption: the top five Southeastern states produced more pulp and paper in 2000 than the top ten states nation-wide produced in 1970!

But pine pulpwood markets are, in a word, lousy.  Southern pulpwood was at or near 25 year lows in 2001.  Widespread outbreaks of Southern Pine Beetle, bringing thousands of acres of "sell at any price" dead timber to market, coupled with an increased volume of CRP (Conservation Reserve Program) Pine Plantation thinning (stands planted in the mid 1980's), has glutted the market for small-diameter wood.  Pulp and Paper Mill overcapacity, created during the last 'boom cycle', has resulted in cutthroat end-product competition.  Prices paid for pulpwood stumpage (standing trees) have tumbled 7% from 1st Quarter 2001.

Hardwood markets are stable.  Oak and Yellow Poplar are in demand throughout the Piedmont.  Hardwood sawtimber stumpage prices were up 5% over the 1st Quarter of 2001, while Hardwood pulpwood prices are up 10% over the one-year period.

Southeastern Average Stumpage Prices (source Timber Mart South):

 

Price

 Per Ton  

Year

 Ago
  1st Q 2002 4th Q 2001 3rd Q 2001 Up/Down Percent
Pine Sawtimber $36.31 $35.95 $34.11 +2.20 +6.4%
Pine Chip-n-Saw $23.50 $23.72 $22.53 +0.97 +4.3%
Pine Pulpwood $6.24 $6.20 $6.73 -0.49 -7.3%
Hardwood Sawtimber $18.68 $18.61 $17.66 +1.02 +5.8%
Hardwood Pulpwood $5.06 $5.16 $4.60 +0.46 +10.0%

 

According to the Atlanta Business Chronicle, "Timber, Georgia's #1 cash crop, has earned money for years for private landowners.  Now, timberland ownership is beginning to attract a herd of institutional investors lured by returns of up to 20 percent annually.  This year the number of institutional investors in privately held timberland has swelled to about 70, mainly pension funds, that have stakes in property worth about $4 billion, or 2 percent, of the total of $200 billion in U.S. timberland assets.  Forest products companies own 24 percent of U.S. timberland, and private investors own the remaining 74 percent."

PieChart - Georgia Forest Ownership

WHOLE-TREE CHIPPER THINNING

Selective Thinning Benefits Allatoona Lake Property

Fall Line Consultants is in the ninth year of a sustained-yield program to thin young pine plantations on the 5200 acre Allatoona Lake property of Willoughby & Sewell Development, Ltd.  Three thousand five hundred (3500) acres will have been thinned by late 2002.

Blowing Chips into Van
Whole-Tree Chipper blows Chips into Van

"Leave" trees, chosen for their potential to produce sawlog-quality timber in the future, are selectively-marked by Fall Line Consultants.  Target density to remain after thinning is 30-35 square feet basal area per acre, equivalent to 75-80 trees per acre averaging 8 inches diameter at breast height.  Trees removed in the thinning, which are of relatively small diameter and short height due to (young) age and competition, are not suitable for conventional, "tree length" logging.
The ideal solution for thinning marginally merchantable plantations was found in the whole-tree chipper.  Trees are harvested with a feller-buncher, skidded to a decking area, and chipped on-site, producing a product suitable for use in pulp making and as boiler fuel.  The chips are blown into vans and trucked to the purchasing mill.

Whole-Tree Chipper
Whole-Tree Chipper

Thinning: Before and After

The whole-tree chipping method has the advantage of increasing yield from the harvested acreage because bark, limbs and otherwise non-merchantable hardwood understory stems are added to the mix.  Fall Line Consultants has noted a 20-35 percent yield bonus over conventional logging of like sized timber.  Game species such as deer, turkeys and quail also benefit from the new browse abundant in the thinned plantations.  New herbaceous growth quickly follows the thinning as sunlight reaches the previously dark forest floor.  [See our Wildlife page for discussion of prescribed burning to improve Quail habitat on thinned plantations.]
Landowners Jim Willoughby and Joe Sewell are pleased with the revenue from these first thinnings and the appearance of the thinned stands.  They can look forward to steady income by thinning young plantations reaching merchantability each year, and to harvest of high-quality, high-value sawtimber stands in the near future.

Thinned Loblolly Pine Plantation
Pine Plantation After Thinning Via Whole-Tree Chipper

Contact Fall Line Consultants, LLC (Mark Barnett 404-271-2573 / Jay Barnett 404-310-1427) for information, or E-Mail Fall Line Consultants

For legal questions (real estate) and downloadable documents, visit Wood & Meredith law firm

FRENCH INVADE GEORGIA

Summer 1998 saw two French forestry students visit Atlanta (Roswell), Georgia and Fall Line Consultants for a two-month internship.  Jean Baptiste Aurel and Hugues de Bronac de Bougainville, French equivalents of Junior and Sophomore, respectively, at Ecole Superieure Du Bois in Nantes, (western) France, were required to do an internship, forestry study and report (thesis) as a condition for graduation.

Hugues & Jean-Baptiste
Hugues (left) and Jean-Baptiste


Hugues and Jean-Baptiste discovered Fall Line Consultants via this web site, and corresponded by e-mail for a few weeks.  As luck would have it, the Allatoona Lake property, on which selectively-marked pin plantation thinning has been conducted annually since 1991, was ripe for a growth study.

Jean-Baptiste and Hugues arrived at Hartsfield International airport (Atlanta) in June, 1998, and soon realized their sweaters would not be needed for the duration of their stay in Georgia!  These two intelligent, hard-working young men adapted to the heat and humidity (and culture shock) of the southeast, and began to systematically sample each thinned stand taking the following measurements on 1/10th acre plots:

bulletSpecies
bulletAge (used increment borer to extract and count growth rings)
bulletDiameter at Breast Height (DBH)
bulletTotal Tree Height
bulletMerchantable (useable) Tree Height
bulletTwo-year and Ten-year Growth Increment (to nearest 1/10 inch)

Their thesis concluded that the "leave" (crop) trees of the earliest-thinned stands do indeed have greater average height, diameter (and age) than the later-thinned stands.  The 'most recent two-year' growth measurements, expressed as an annual rate, were significantly higher than the 'last ten-year' annualized growth rate.  The study demonstrates numerically what can be seen clearly by visual inspection of tree growth rings -- these trees, from both a silvicultural and economic perspective, needed to be thinned because growth (evidenced by width of the rings) was slowing in the years prior to thinning.  Growth of the "leave" trees increased in the years immediately following thinning.

Across the studied years of thinning, from 1991-1998, the "current" two-year growth rate showed a 10.9 percent increase over the ten-year annualized growth rate.  Looking at just those stands thinned before 1997 (because the stands thinned in 1997-98 had not had sufficient time for the "growth response" to manifest in the rings), the "current" two-year annualized growth rate showed a 29.5 percent increase over the ten-year annualized growth rate!

W&S Crossroads

We enjoyed our association with Jean-Baptiste and Hugues, and wish them great success in their forestry careers.  During their Georgia internship, J.B and "Ug" learned about the forestry consulting business, how to set up and supervise timber sales, whole-tree chipper and conventional timber thinning, and forest industry practices in the southeastern United States.

DIRECTOR MIXON SPEAKS

Timber Transaction Important Decision

The following column by John W. Mixon, Director, Georgia Forestry Commission, is reprinted from the "Farmers and Consumers Market Bulletin".

The sale of timber is often a once-in-a-lifetime transaction and, as a private non-industrial landowner, you deserve the best possible price for the trees you have managed and protected for 25 or perhaps even 45 long years.  If you are ready to sell, I highly recommend that you obtain the services of a professional consulting forester who is registered to practice in Georgia.  A list of these professionals is available at all Georgia Forestry Commission offices throughout the state.

After retaining a consultant, you should discuss what you wish to accomplish on your property; there are usually several options and the forester can help you make a sound decision.  You will want to review fees, learn how the sale is to be handled and discuss the type of inspection that will be made during the harvest to insure protection of your land.  A good sound contract, of course, protects both the seller and the buyer.

You may want to talk to other landowners that have engaged the consultant you have in mind before you actually enter into an agreement to use his services.

Consulting foresters keep abreast of the current prices of the various products that can be processed from your timber such as pulpwood, chip-n-saw, sawtimber, plywood logs, poles and pilings.  By merchandising timber for the highest-price product, it will naturally sell for the best possible price.  The consulting forester can handle all aspects of the timber sale, including regeneration, if you desire.  Most landowners find that the consultant fees are more than offset by the higher selling price he or she often secures for the timber . . .

Visit the Georgia Forestry Commission web site

ATLANTA BUSINESS CHRONICLE REPORTS

(August 14, 1997)  TIMBERLAND is both a factory and a warehouse.  Even when timber and pulp prices sag, trees keep growing.  Timberland investments between 1960 and 1995 have had average annual returns of 13.65 percent, compared with 10.74 percent annually for common stocks and 7.58 percent annually for corporate bonds during the same period.

INTENSIVE PINE MANAGEMENT EXPLORED

Georgia growers could double or even triple yields from pine plantations if they would adopt intensive management practices like those already being used in Brazil, Chile and South Africa, according to the findings of a new study by Drs. Bruce Borders and Bob Bailey, researchers at the University of Georgia's Warnell School of Forest Resources.

"Our research shows that current growth rates of loblolly pines in the Southeast aren't even close to their potential" said Borders.  "While the hot, humid climate -- and the absence of native insect and disease pests -- may boost growth rates of southern yellow pines south of the equator, the accelerated growth is largely the result of intensive practices that include extensive site preparation, weed control, cultivation and fertilization."

The study, Loblolly Pine: Pushing the Limits of Growth, which was funded by Georgia Power Company and the Georgia Forestry Commission, includes nine years of data from several sites across the state.  Surprisingly, the study showed the largest gains in growth come not from fertilization, but from controlling hardwood seedlings and other competing vegetation alone", said Borders.  "We know we can easily double production simply by controlling vegetation alone."

Pines in the study that received yearly fertilization and weed control grew at rates two to three times faster than trees in standard loblolly plantations in the Southeast.  And while Borders said it is difficult to predict the quality of wood that will come from these 'fast-tracked' trees, he added that they can produce three or four times more fiber on the same land base.  "It is not unreasonable to believe that current fiber rotation lengths can be reduced from 20 to 25 years to just 12 or 15 years, while doubling or even tripling fiber production on a given acre of ground."

Borders warns that intensive management is not appropriate for all sites or all situations.  Like row cropping, intensive pine production should not be practiced on steep slopes or in environmentally sensitive situations.

Auburn Forestry

Auburn University School of Forestry web site

WOOD FACTS

Are We Running Out of Trees? Are We Running Out of Hardwoods?

ISSUE:  Sometimes news reports make it seem like there is not a tree left in North America.  What are the facts?

ISSUE: Hardwoods are the broad-leafed trees that lose their leaves each autumn, like oak, maple, cherry and ash.  How are these forests doing today?

FACTS: FACTS:
bulletWe still have 70 percent of the forests that were here in 1600 -- 737 million acres of forests in the U.S.
 
bullet247 million acres are reserved from harvest by law or are slow-growing woodlands unsuitable for timber production.
 
bullet490 million acres are called timberlands, forests that can produce more than 20 cubic feet of wood per acre annually.  They are growing more trees today than 40 years ago.
 
bulletThe timberlands of the U.S. now contain 28 percent more standing timber volume than in 1952.  Canada has over one billion acres of forests, 263 million more than the U.S.  From 1986-1989, only 1.2 percent of Canada's 576 million acres of timberlands were harvested.
bulletForest Resources of the United States, 1992, shows that in the U.S., we are growing far more hardwoods each year than are harvested and lost to fire, insects and disease.  In 1991, for example, growth exceeded harvest and mortality by 19 percent.
 
bulletThere are 82 percent more hardwoods today than 40 years ago.
 
bulletIn the U.S. most hardwoods grow east of the Mississippi River.  In Canada they are most abundant in Quebec and Ontario.
 
bulletHardwoods are most often used to make fine furniture, kitchen cabinets, flooring, paneling, high-quality paper and firewood.  They are also used to make musical instruments such as electric guitars and pianos, baseball bats, hockey sticks, bowling pins and photographic film.


Conifer or Broadleaf?

TIMBER APPRAISAL IN NEW MEXICO

New Mexico Measurements

In early 1999, Fall Line Consultants was called upon by an Atlanta-based timber investment group to inspect and appraise a 7000 acre wooded property in northeastern New Mexico.  These rocky foothills offer breathtaking vistas of the mesas below, and support forests of (mostly) Ponderosa Pine, Douglas Fir, White Fir, Spruce and Aspen.  In the photo left, we are taking sample measurements (height, diameter, etc.) for the timber inventory.

With a shorter growing season (than the Southeastern U.S.) and much less rainfall, mature trees attain a height and diameter similar to southern yellow pine, but take many more years to reach this state.  Trees killed (by old age, insects, disease) do not rot -- they remain on the forest floor in the arid climate, creating a tinderbox for devastating wildfires in the future.  Unfortunately, the logging industry has been curtailed by government regulations and a 'preservation' mindset amongst the general public, and markets for smaller-diameter trees, which would be harvested in a thinning to improve forest health and reduce fire hazard, are virtually non-existent.

State-owned (Bureau of Land Management) lands encompass millions of acres in New Mexico, and from a timber perspective are being "managed" by benign neglect.  State Foresters know what should be done (i.e., thinning), but are prevented from taking appropriate action by bureaucratic red-tape and regulations.  Expect to be hearing news reports about New Mexico conflagrations in years to come!

The investment group continues to seek a large timberland-ranch in northeastern New Mexico.  Fall Line Consultants hopes soon to be managing New Mexico acreage, in an economically and ecologically sound manner, for timber and wildlife production.  It is truly beautiful country, and we look forward to our return.

Visit the New Mexico Forestry Division

Ponderosa Pine

 

Update (June, 2002):  Serious wildfires have indeed hit New Mexico and the Western U.S. since our visit.  [see the Wildfire page]  A bad fire season is projected for summer/fall 2002.  In New Mexico, legislation has been introduced which would encourage the harvest and salvage of pulpwood (small diameter) trees to reduce the incidence and severity of wildfires.  Let's hope loggers and markets can be developed again in New Mexico to make this initiative work! 

Wildfire in Western U.S.