This was written about finished by Matt in December. This and my
(this is Andrew typing) Intelligent Life Paper
were both written for the same english project. I would've put this
up sooner, but I've been really busy lately and this kept getting
put off.
Thoughts of Ghosts and other "spooky" phenomena come to some peoples'
minds whenever they think about the word paranormal. But those same
people probably don't know that the word ‘Paranormal' also has some
scientific ties as well, such as the paranormal ‘science' of Psychometry.
Psychometry is just one example of the few ties that I am going
to show between science and the Paranormal.
The ability to see things that aren't there can be classified as
Paranormal. Yet, all the supposed "Psychics", aren't very Paranormal
as far as popular belief goes. So what does it take for something
to be believably classified as paranormal? Usually, just something
that doesn't seem to fit into any sort of logic, and therefore is
unexplainable. But what about things like Psychometry, which I mentioned
earlier?
Psychometry is the measure of the soul of things. It as developed
by a man named Joseph Rhodes Buchanon in 1849. (Haining, 142) The
main theory behind it is that the information that was conveyed
through emotions somehow recorded on objects by those previously
associated with them. How is there a connection between science
and the paranormal? Well, for one thing, nothing at all like this
was ever recorded in History. It doesn't seem to fit into any explainable
category as demonstrated by the various scientific tests performed.
William Denton, an English immigrant to America, performed numerous
experiments on people and in doing so, became ‘sensitive' to it
himself. He believed that Psychometry was a "mysterious faculty
which belongs to the soul and is not dependent upon the body for
its exercise." (North, 77) All of Denton's experiments proved the
theory of Psychometry to be true, with the greatest example being
his wife. He gave her a fragment of volcanic lava from Hawaii. She
saw "an ocean of fire pouring over a precipice and boiling as it
pours. I see it flow into the ocean, and the water boils intensely."
(North, 77)
The belief that an object can transpose a whole history to any
one person just by being around it seems, in essence, the whole
definition of paranormal. But the scientific ends of Psychometry
don't end there. Variations on the theory of it were created. Sir
Oliver Lodge, believed that a phenomenon similar to Psychometry
could account for Hauntings. He wrote in 1908, "On a psychometric
hypothesis, the original tragedy has been literally photographed
on its material surroundings, may, even on the ether itself, by
reason of the intensity of emotion felt by those who enacted it,
and thenceforth in certain persons an hallucinatory effect is experienced
corresponding to such an impression." (North, 78) Then in 1963,
a British psychical researcher named Tom Lethbridge, came up with
another variation. He suggested that nature generates fields of
static electricity, particularly near running water and that these
fields are capable of recording the feelings of people. Based on
this most recent variation came another adaptation. Robert Morris
was the first incumbent of the Koestler chair in Parapsychology
at Edinburg University in Scotland.
He performed the most significant science experiment on the "emotional
tape-recording." He took a rat, a dog, a cat, and a rattlesnake
into a room where a murder had been committed. His results were
astounding. The dog snarled and refused to go in. The cat lept up
onto its owner's shoulders with it's back out and it's hair up.
The rattlesnake immediately adopted its attack posture, and the
rat didn't seem to mind too much. So to say that the Paranormal
and Science have no connection would be incorrect. (Leone, Bender,
238)
For another connection between the two, I look no further than
the ever-popular belief known as Telepathy. Telepathy is generally
known s mind-to-mind contact without resort to the five known senses.
It comes from the Greek words "tele", meaning distant, and "pathe",
or feeling. There are literally thousands of telepathic cases on
record. Most people can recall incidents where telepathy was a possible
factor. "I remember the day my wife and I were discussing girl's
names for a possible future daughter. Mid-way through the conversation
I went to the toilet. As I came downstairs on the way back the name
‘Lucy' entered my head. I walked into the lounge and my wife said,
‘How about Lucy?' ". (White, 119) So many people believed in the
scientific element of Telepathy that they even founded a society
for Psychical research. One of its founders, F.W.H. Myers, believed
so strongly in the belief that Telepathy would be understood that
he wrote in the proceedings of the society: "The society for Psychical
research was founded with the establishment of thought transference
already rising within measurable distance of proof." (White, 118)
He was to be severely saddened when proof was to become elusive,
and the academic acceptance he was trying to gather was almost impossible
to obtain. One of the main problems that made widespread acceptance
of Telepathy hard to come by was admirably identified by the early
Psychical researcher Dame Edith Lyttleton. She said, "Telepathy
does not merely bridge space, it annihilates it- space becomes irrelevance."
(White, 119) That's where the problem comes in. Our scientific model
of how the universe works demands that space must be crossed in
line with the laws allowing such movement. Telepathy, in that instance,
breaks every single rule of what we have commonly come to understand
as reality.
Movements of thoughts from one mind to another in an instantaneous
manner condemns everything that a scientist holds near and dear.
Scientists have to prove everything. And proof hasn't been easy
to come by. The most commonly documented form of telepathic communication
comes during what has been termed a "crisis situation". Usually
it occurs when an individual becomes "aware" that another- usually
a friend or relative- is in danger or has died. Often such information
can filter into the mind during sleep, when it surfaces as a dream.
Upon waking up, it can manifest as a feeling of certainty or as
knowledge that inexplicably pops up during a conversation in which
the speaker is unaware of why he said that someone has just died,
for example, or where the information came from. (Leone, Bender,
152) The scientific cause for telepathy can only be confirmed in
the sheer number of cases. Many people report "seeing" friends or
relatives at the time of their death elsewhere. Telepathy, or coincidence?
Don't decide until you hear this next example.
From time to time, memories from the sunken unconscious mind can
surface. Not recognized as memories, they seem like original ideas.
This is the paranormal phenomena known as Cryptomnesia. Many researchers
have analysed past-life regression through hypnosis. One of the
first was the French Psychic researcher colonel Albert de Rochas.
Beginning in 1904, he hypnotized nineteen subjects, with his results
being that they all easily manifested past lives. However, the realization
also came to him that the verification of these lives was extremely
difficult; he often found inconsistencies between historical records
and testimony under hynosis. Human error? Or were the past-lives
that the subjects manifested, more accurate than our history books?
(Leone, Bender, 241)
There is evidence, too, of another sort. It comes from Psychotherapy.
The sanctioning of hypnosis as valid clinical treatment by the British
Medical Association in 1955, and by its American equivalent three
years later, led to the development of a whole new type of therapy;
past-life therapy. Since the 1960s, dozens of therapists have cured
a whole multitude of phobias, fears and aversions by taking their
patents back to traumas experienced in previous lives. Dr. Denys
Kelsey is one psychotherapist who has used hypnotic regression to
treat a host of psychosomatic ailments. One patient was a young
woman who had a deep-seated fear of flying. Taking her back, "beyond
birth", Dr. Kelsey brought out an incarnation of a British Royal
Air Force officer who had been trapped in his cockpit and faced
the terror of crashing. Once the woman was aware of this previous
incarnation, she was able to overcome her fear.
That form of therapy was so successful, that in 1980, therapists
got together to form the Association for Past Life Research and
Therapy in Riverside, California. In 1982, one therapist by the
name of Dr. Helen Wambach, decided to survey the past-life therapy
through the association. Analyzing data from twenty-six therapists,
she gleaned the astounding fact that out of 18,463 patients, Ninety
four percent had regressed to one or more past lives. Trauma is
often associated with denial of the reasons for the manifestation
of the problem. Going to a therapist who practices past-life regression
and connecting the trauma with a previous life makes it easier for
the patient to identify the problem.
Cryptomnesia does not fit the accepted scientific memory model
as presently understood. Memory is the fallout of knowledge based
upon the learning processes. We do something in life, and the event
is encoded as memory, so as to improve our behavior or regulate
our activity. The predominant scientific view of memory is that
such information is stored in nerve fibers within the brain. The
actual process of memorizing is said to exist in two specific forms.
In order to avoid unnecessary memorization, the brain has capabilities
for short-term memory and long term memory. For Cryptomnesia to
work in the context of past-life recall, the source of the past
life must have been passed to long-term memory. Cryptomnesia doesn't
fit what we know about memory recall. To try and "explain" reincarnation
with Cryptomnesia is to answer a mystery with a mystery. (Leone,
Bender, 241-243)
These three examples of what are called "Paranormal Sciences" are
completely different in what they are about. Yet, in all three,
there are certainly strong cases that can be made for scientific
involvement. The problem is that we still don't know how to do that
in a way where it will be widely accepted and believed. So the "sciences"
known as Psychometry, Telepathy, and Cryptomnesia are not accepted
as normal. They are, in a word, paranormal.
Matthew Wittnebel
Lone Conspirator
Works Cited
North, Anthony. The Paranormal: A Guide to the Unexplained. United
Kingdom: Blandford, 1996.
Haining, Peter. Dictionary of Ghost Lore. New Jersey: Prentice-Hall,
1984.
Leone, Bruno and L. Bender, David. Paranormal Phenomena. San Diego:
Greenhaven Press, 1991.
White, Michael. Weird Science. New York: Avon Books, 1999.
Davidson, Joshua. A Skeptics Guide to the Paranormal. 13 May 1998
Scientific Press 12 Nov. 2001.
[Editors note- Don't take any of the comments in this article personally.
If you are offended by any of the comments within this article,
just remember this one very important thing: The Lone Conspirators
cannot be held responsible for any of the actions/writings contained
in this website that may contain obscene/offensive material. Don't
believe us? Then read our Mission Statement.]
Back